GIBSON WILL BE REMEMBERED AS A FAILURE

It was about two weeks ago, when the CPL teams were in St. Kitts for the final leg of the 2014 competition that I had Jamaica Tallawahs coach Mickey Arthur on my sports talk show on Nationwide Radio talking about what is going to be required to turn the Tallawahs fortunes around after consecutive poor batting displays that saw them losing two matches to the Zouks and Tridents.

Call it intuition or whatever you want but as I prepared to conclude the conversation I squeezed in one last question. I asked the South Arican coach whether or not he would consider coaching the West Indies Test team. In response, Arthur said it was a job he would consider down the road but said that it was a job he would take.

Now, as I said before I had no prior knowledge about the impending departure of West Indies coach Ottis Gibson, who in my estimation had achieved very little in his four years in charge. It was back in February 2010 that Gibson was employed by the West Indies Board after he had had a successful stint as the bowling coach of England.

He was on my radio show shortly thereafter and during the interview sounded like a no-nonsense kind of guy. He was, to me, what the West Indies needed to stem the perceived indiscipline that was rampant within the ranks of the team that was floundering near the bottom of the Test rankings.

Four years later, the only accolade the West Indies can claim is that 2012 T20 trophy. Everything else is basically the same. Other than that trophy, Gibson’s tenure as coach will be remembered for his battles with Chris Gayle and Ramnaresh Sarwan. The latter claimed Gibson destroyed his confidence. Gayle was banned from playing for the West Indies after he delivered scathing remarks against Gibson on KLAS radio and refused to apologize. Michael Holding even called for the coach to learn how to man-manage.

What is boils down to was this. Under Gibson’s charge the West Indies played 29 Tests. They won 9 and lost 16. They also played 90 one day internationals winning 36 and losing 48. As it relates to T20 internationals they played 45, winning 22 and losing 21. The team is eighth in the ICC Test rankings, eighth in the ODI rankings and seventh in the T2o rankings.

After four years in charge that was not good enough. Regardless of whatever other unknown factors that came to play in the decision of the West Indies Cricket Board and Gibson to part company with immediate effect, the bottom line is after four years in charge the more he tried to change the more things remained the same, Gibson’s legacy was one of abject failure.

Should Mickey Arthur eventually be appointed coach of the West Indies, he will have his hands full in transforming the fortunes of this team that somehow has failed to take a decent step forward in a decade or more. He will perhaps find things not to his liking, but it would be hard to conceive him doing worse than Gibson.

The opinions on this page do not necessarily reflect the views of The Gleaner.
The Gleaner reserves the right not to publish comments that may be deemed libelous, derogatory or indecent.
To respond to The Gleaner please use the feedback form.

3 Responses to “GIBSON WILL BE REMEMBERED AS A FAILURE”

  1. Michael Chambers says:

    I would have wanted to see Gibson gone much earlier, but I would not consider his tenure with the West Indies a failure. There is a saying if the head of the stream is dirty don’t expect the stream to be clean. Our Problem was with the WICB. Now that we have a new Board we are starting to see change. Change in the culture at the selection committee level, emphasis on development of youth cricket.

    I am confident that in the next 2 years we should start seeing results.
    Gibson planted the seeds, now let us wait for them to grow.

    Wishing him all the best.

    Michael Chambers,
    US Cricket Hall of Fame

  2. dallo says:

    at the outset, gibson and sammy looked like they were on to something as the team showed signs of becoming a grittier, more disciplined unit.

    that push pretty much petered out as time went by and right now, we’re still minnows in the test arena.

    it’s kinda strange how we have top-of-the-line capability in the t20 format and yet a bunch of duds in the traditional game. perhaps it’s no coincidence, as that’s where the big bucks are.

    seems like a mindset to me.

  3. Paris Taylor says:

    Gibson was a total disaster and it is as simple as that. We need not rejoice at his shortcomings but try and build on what he did to our cricket. It is unfortunate what he did to Gayle, Sarwan and Chanderpaul in reducing their playing days when they were bright prospects in West Indies cricket. He came with power which he did not manage well. Certainly he does not know how to handle power when he has it. He felt more or less that power should be absolute. West Indies could have achieved more under his stewardship but he was too heavy handed.

Leave a Reply

3 comments so far
levyl Posted by: levyl August 20, 2014 at 2:18 pm